Have you drained the oil? Were there any metal shavings? I had a similar issue and it ended up being my stator. The starter would spin and the gears inside would spin but the motor wouldn't turn over. Who ever put it in before I bought the quad put the stator in with the wires loose. When I pulled it out all the wires were stripped and some were cut. Pull the stator cover; just like yamahauler said. Try and turn the starter clutch(the big gear behind the flywheel) by hand. Also, check to make sure the other gears are intact. As far as a stator gasket, I've used RTV and it worked just fine. I have also used the paper kind, and they're cheap enough. I used RTV because it was a Saturday night and I wanted to go ride Sunday morning.